Overview of
Transhumanist and Bioconservative
Politics
|
|
|
Libertarian
Transhumanists |
Democratic
Transhumanists |
Left-wing BioLuddites |
Natural Law
BioLuddites |
|
Exemplary Groups |
Extropy Institute
Longevity Meme |
Techprogressives
Technoliberationists
CybDemites
Radical Cyborgs
|
Society for Genetics and Society
Council for Responsible Genetics
ETC
Group |
Center for Bioethics and Culture
Center for Bioethics and Human Dignity |
| |
World Transhumanist Association
Institute for
Ethics and Emerging Technologies
Betterhumans
|
Institute on Biotechnology and the Human
Future |
|
Citizenship |
Personhood-based
“cyborg citizenship":
All self-aware beings with desires and
plans for the future should be
considered citizens with a right to life
|
Limited Human-Racism:
“Humanness” determines citizenship, but
not for embryos |
(Religious)
Human-Racism:
“Humanness” determines citizenship
(Deep Ecological)
Eco-centrism:
Human beings have equal rights with all
living things |
|
Humanism vs. Natural Law |
Humanism:
Human beings are free to determine their
own future, guided by prudent reason.
There are no obvious natural or divine
limits on human aspiration. |
Opposition to (Capitalist/ Imperialist/
Patriarchal) Humanism |
Deep Ecology/Hubris Taboo:
Humanity should be restricted by divine
or ecological taboos |
|
Individual Liberty vs.
Yuck Factor |
Individual liberty
trumps yuck factor |
Yuck factor
trumps individual liberty in germinal
choice and biotech, but not in sexuality
or abortion |
Yuck factor
trumps individual liberty |
|
Technological Risks |
Resignation:
Technology is uncontrollable, government
intervention always has bad unforeseen
consequences, and risks are manageable
without government |
Regulation:
Risks are manageable with the assistance
of democratic oversight and management |
Relinquishment:
Risks are so enormous and unknowable,
and regulatory institutions so flawed,
that human enhancement should be banned |
|
|
Libertarian
Transhumanists |
Democratic Transhumanists |
Left-wing BioLuddites |
Natural Law BioLuddites |
|
The Equality
Challenge of
Enhancement Technology
|
Market Access and Legal Equality Enough:
If legal equality is guaranteed and
enhancement technologies are available
in the market, social equality is
irrelevant and government should do
nothing to create a more equal society |
Make Enhancement Universally Accessible:
Democracies should work toward social
equality, and provide universal access
to enhancement technologies |
Bans on Technologies as Part of Larger
Egalitarian Program:
Democracies should work toward social
equality and ban enhancement
technologies |
Tech Bans Necessary to Protect Equality:
Equality can be guaranteed by banning
enhancement technologies |
|
Procreative Liberty |
Procreative Liberty:
Trust parents to act in kids best
interests, and let them buy germinal
choice in the market. |
Procreative Liberty, Equality and
Beneficence:
Trust parents to act in kids’ best
interests, stop them if they don’t, give
them equal access to germinal choice
technology, and encourage them to create
children with the best life
opportunities. |
Limited Procreative Liberty:
Reproductive rights, but not extended to
germinal choice and reproductive
technology. |
Procreative Liberty Trumped by Natural
Law:
Reproductive rights trumped by religious
prohibitions or the need for radical
population reduction. |
|
Ecological Protection |
Free Market Green:
The market can solve all ecological
problems |
TechnoGaian:
A combination of judicious regulation
and ecologically-oriented technologies
can prevent and remediate ecological
damage. |
Left Ecology:
Technologies developed by patriarchal,
capitalist systems need to be banned and
those systems changed. |
Deep Ecology:
Humanity should radically restrict
itself.
(Religious) Dominion Theology:
Man has stewardship over Nature. |
|
|
Libertarian
Transhumanists |
Democratic Transhumanists |
Left-wing BioLuddites |
Natural Law BioLuddites |
|
Structural Unemployment
|
The Market will Provide:
If the government avoids meddling
(unemployment insurance, minimum wages,
etc.) all workers will find new jobs,
even if at lower wages. |
Embrace the End of Work:
The wealth and leisure created by
automation should be shared equitably by
all through a basic income guarantee and
shorter work week. |
Protectionism, Luddism, Public
Employment:
Attempt to protect existing jobs, and
create new ones. |
(EcoLuddite) Small is Beautiful:
Stop automation and adopt voluntary
simplicity. |
|
Globalization |
Economic globalization good:
Global governance, worker protections,
environmental laws, all unnecessary |
Economic globalization must be
accompanied by political globalization:
Economic globalization good so long as
it is accompanied by worker rights and
protections, environmental laws, and
global democratic governance of capital
flows.
|
(EcoLuddite) Globalization should be
stopped:
Return to local self-reliance and
political sovereignity
(Religious)
Global bans on enhancement tech
Global treaties to ban cloning and
enhancement, but no other global
governance |