The IEET is a 501(c)3 non-profit, tax-exempt organization registered in the State of Connecticut in the United States. Please give as you are able, and help support our work for a brighter future.
Thomas Metzinger is the Director of the Philosophy Group at the Department of Philosophy at Johannes Gutenberg-University Mainz. His research focuses on philosophy of mind, especially on consciousness and the nature of the self. In this lecture he develops a representationalist theory of phenomenal self-consciousness.
That's kind of like asking if there is a river, and if not, what's my boat floating on. On the one hand there is a constantly changing body of water that floats boats. On the other the river is just an illusion since the water is constantly changing - it has no essential riverness. In this case if we examine the working of the mind there is no stable, discrete, continuous observer, there is just a process of observation and memory, sun by a variety of sub-systems. As to falsifiability I'll have to think about it. But since the dominant hypothesis is the idea of an observer it seems there is as much pressure to find data to find support for that hypothesis given the counter evidence suggested by Metzinger et al.
Posted by anon on 04/01 at 07:31 PM
"there is just a process of observation and memory"
Performed by who or what? Who is doing the observing? What is recalling the memory?
I'm afraid that you are just playing word games.
You may as well claim that a fun house hall of mirrors is somehow self aware since it is constantly relfecting on itself.
Your "explanation" does nothing to bridge the explanatory gap.
My personal view on the matter is that of the new mysterians: the ind in principle can never be explained in material terms. That is not tos say that it isn't necessarily pure material, only that amaterial explainaion for "self", "qualia", "awareness" etc. will never be possible.
Posted by David on 11/02 at 06:50 PM
Nothing is observing. The observation is a process that occurs. The observation generally inaccurately labels what it observes and then observing itself it labels itself as "Self".
Posted by veronica on 11/03 at 02:38 AM
"The observation is a process that occurs."
David, have you just discovered the "uncaused cause"?
Posted by CygnusX1 on 11/03 at 03:45 PM
"To be or not to be.. that is illogical captain!"
... or is it?
Consciousness as phenomena and not merely phenomenological?
IEET Blog |
email list |
newsletter |
The IEET is a 501(c)3 non-profit, tax-exempt organization registered in the State of Connecticut in the United States.
Contact: Executive Director, Dr. James J. Hughes,
Williams 119, Trinity College, 300 Summit St., Hartford CT
06106 USA
Email: director @ ieet.org phone:
860-297-2376
IEET Blog