Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies


The IEET is a 501(c)3 non-profit, tax-exempt organization registered in the State of Connecticut in the United States. Please give as you are able, and help support our work for a brighter future.


Search the IEET
Subscribe and Contribute to:


Technoprogressive? BioConservative? Huh?
Quick overview of biopolitical points of view




whats new at ieet

The one percent discovers transhumanism: Davos 2016

The wonderful and terrifying implications of computers that can learn

“McMindfulness”: is Buddhism contaminated by capitalism?” - interview with Terry Hyland

Stefan Sorgner co-organizing 8th Beyond Humanism Conference in Madrid

The Value of Deep Work and How to Prioritise It

Should you be able to patent a human gene?


ieet books

Keywords for Environmental Studies
Author
eds. Joni Adamson, William A. Gleason, David N. Pellow


comments

RJP8915 on 'Ray Kurzweil’s Basic Ideas' (Feb 6, 2016)

spud100 on 'Is Cheap Oil a Bad Thing?' (Feb 6, 2016)

John G Mess on 'Ray Kurzweil’s Basic Ideas' (Feb 6, 2016)

RJP8915 on 'Ray Kurzweil’s Basic Ideas' (Feb 6, 2016)

Barbara546 on 'My Gay Marriage in USA Prediction was Incredibly Wrong, by 20 Years - Hooray!' (Feb 6, 2016)

g3reth on '"McMindfulness": is Buddhism contaminated by capitalism?" - interview with Terry Hyland' (Feb 6, 2016)

almostvoid on 'The Value of Deep Work and How to Prioritise It' (Feb 6, 2016)







Subscribe to IEET News Lists

Daily News Feed

Longevity Dividend List

Catastrophic Risks List

Biopolitics of Popular Culture List

Technoprogressive List

Trans-Spirit List



JET

Enframing the Flesh: Heidegger, Transhumanism, and the Body as “Standing Reserve”

Moral Enhancement and Political Realism

Intelligent Technologies and Lost Life

Hottest Articles of the Last Month


“Technology Could Bring Heaven on Earth, or Create Hell” - interview with futurist Gerd Leonhard
Jan 9, 2016
(9111) Hits
(1) Comments

Becoming the First Transhuman: A Call For The Right Stuff
Jan 17, 2016
(7149) Hits
(2) Comments

First Successful Gene-Editing in Live Mammals Brings Us Closer to Human Treatments
Jan 22, 2016
(4815) Hits
(0) Comments

The Singularity: Fact or Fiction or Somewhere In-between?
Jan 13, 2016
(4382) Hits
(17) Comments



IEET > Rights > Neuroethics > Life > Access > Enablement > Vision > Technoprogressivism > Staff > Kyle Munkittrick

Print Email permalink (2) Comments (5951) Hits •  subscribe Share on facebook Stumble This submit to reddit submit to digg


Enhancers are Not “Cheating”


Kyle Munkittrick
By Kyle Munkittrick
Science Not Fiction

Posted: Mar 9, 2011

Placing a ban on cognitive-enhancing drugs won’t do anything positive, and neither will creating an attitude of disapproval.

Matt Lamkin argues here that universities shouldn’t ban cognitive-enhancing drugs like Ritalin and Adderall. Lamkin is a lawyer and, like myself, a master’s candidate in bioethics. He rightly believes that a ban would do little to promote fairness or safety among students. The rule followers would be at a disadvantage while the rule-breakers would be at a greater safety risk.

But Lamkin doesn’t believe we, as a society, should be OK with cognitive enhancement usage. Instead, he argues:

The word “cheating” has another meaning, one that has nothing to do with competition. When someone has achieved an end through improper means, we might say that person has “cheated herself” out of whatever rewards are inherent in the proper means. The use of study drugs by healthy students could corrode valuable practices that education has traditionally fostered. If, for example, students use such drugs to mitigate the consequences of procrastination, they may fail to develop mental discipline and time-management skills.

On the other hand, Ritalin might enable a student to engage more deeply in college and to more fully experience its internal goods-goods she might be denied without that assistance. The distinction suggests that a blanket policy, whether of prohibition or universal access, is unlikely to be effective.

Instead, colleges need to encourage students to engage in the practice of education rather than to seek shortcuts. Instead of ferreting out and punishing students, universities should focus on restoring a culture of deep engagement in education, rather than just competition for credentials.

drugsLamkin’s argument is that cog-enhancers are an easy way out for those in school. Struggling to study builds character and good habits. Though he disapproves of cog-enhancers, I appreciate his hesitancy to involve the law. Lamkin doesn’t believe policing cog-enhancing drug usage is necessary, but would prefer honor codes opposing cog-enhancing drugs. He believes honor codes cause one to “internalize” the value of not using the drug.

What is curious is that Lamkin doesn’t actually address what Ritalin and Adderall do for a student. As a person who has a legit prescription for Ritalin, and who knows his fair share of folks who’ve taken Adderall off-label, I believe I can speak to how cog-enhancers work in at least an anecdotal sense…

READ THE REST


Kyle Munkittrick, IEET Program Director: Envisioning the Future, is a recent graduate of New York University, where he received his Master's in bioethics and critical theory.
Nicole Sallak Anderson is a Computer Science graduate from Purdue University. She developed encryption and network security software, which inspired the eHuman Trilogy—both eHuman Dawn and eHuman Deception are available at Amazon, the third installment is expected in early 2016. She is a member of the advisory board for the Lifeboat Foundation and the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies.
Print Email permalink (2) Comments (5952) Hits •  subscribe Share on facebook Stumble This submit to reddit submit to digg


COMMENTS


Congrats on being published in Discover; that’s a big deal.
This is a good essay. You make a great case for concentration vs. motivation.
A study published in April of 2010 seemed to show that 71%of those misusing the cog drugs “screen positive for ADHD symptoms” (Peterkin, http://jad.sagepub.com/content/early/2010/04/20/1087054710365980.abstract). So, are the drugs in question for a majority of users really enhancement drugs?





Thank you for this important article.





YOUR COMMENT (IEET's comment policy)

Login or Register to post a comment.

Next entry: From Tunisia and Egypt to Wisconsin: Anonymous Hacker Group Helps Take Down Insupportable Websites

Previous entry: Ayesha Khanna Appointed as IEET Fellow

HOME | ABOUT | FELLOWS | STAFF | EVENTS | SUPPORT  | CONTACT US
SECURING THE FUTURE | LONGER HEALTHIER LIFE | RIGHTS OF THE PERSON | ENVISIONING THE FUTURE
CYBORG BUDDHA PROJECT | AFRICAN FUTURES PROJECT | JOURNAL OF EVOLUTION AND TECHNOLOGY

RSSIEET Blog | email list | newsletter |
The IEET is a 501(c)3 non-profit, tax-exempt organization registered in the State of Connecticut in the United States.

East Coast Contact: Executive Director, Dr. James J. Hughes,
56 Daleville School Rd., Willington CT 06279 USA 
Email: director @ ieet.org     phone: 860-428-1837

West Coast Contact: Managing Director, Hank Pellissier
425 Moraga Avenue, Piedmont, CA 94611
Email: hank @ ieet.org