Fearing the Wrong Monsters
Mike Treder
2009-10-31 00:00:00

In modern times we've seen the same intensity of fear-mongering wielded by fascist dictators and also by democratic leaders. Recall the "red scare" of the 1950s, the "evil empire" of the 1980s, and the personification of all that is unholy in Saddam Hussein.

This cynical use of fear by people in leadership positions, often aided by a compliant media, sometimes can be used to accomplish worthy purposes, as in fighting the Axis during World War II. But more often it is simply a tool for accruing more power, wealth, or influence to the leader and his in-group. Note the choice of Hussein as the baddest man in the world, for example, when there were several other despots arguably doing far worse things to their people but who didn't happen, oddly enough, to occupy land replete with valuable oil reserves.

In the long run, of course, a tremendously greater amount of damage will be done to the Earth and all its inhabitants by greedy oil barons and industrial tycoons who support phony think tanks and pay alleged "scientists" to propagate disinformation about the real dangers of climate change. Their interests, and the financial futures of the politicians they buy, are made more secure when they can distract us from the truth by building up the fear of nasty enemies.

It's natural, mind you, for humans (and other thinking animals) to be afraid of that which is strange to them. Without this innate caution toward the unfamiliar, we'd be likely to take undue risks. Fear is a normal, healthy reaction to certain stimuli, but it also can be misused to our detriment.

While it's not surprising that new scientific and technological developments often cause fearful reactions, it's clearly necessary for cooler heads to prevail and allow for the spread of beneficial innovations. From the printing press and the weaving machine to the locomotive and the telegraph, from blood transfusions and vaccinations to in vitro fertilization and stem cell research, certain advances will predictably spur a negative backlash. Over the years, these advances come to be seen as less threatening and eventually are welcomed and accepted by all but a fringe minority.

In our own time, we're seeing the bogeyman fear applied to concepts associated with transhumanism -- "the world's most dangerous idea" -- but as we move further into the 21st century, new techniques in genetic engineering, robotics, human-computer interfaces, nanomedicine, and other emerging technologies also will come to be accepted as routine and generally valuable.

Earlier in the Industrial Era, fearful depictions of monsters created by human meddling were a common theme in science fiction novels and movies. Examples include Frankenstein, Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, The Island of Doctor Moreau, The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, Metropolis, and Brave New World. (Notice all the 'doctors'?)

Modern day characterizations of the same monstrous fears can be found in the Terminator movies, along with Blade Runner, Gattaca, The Matrix, and many others.

Strangely, a small subculture of transhumanist thinkers have created a similar fear of dangerously diabolical inhuman products of advanced technology, this time in the form of an "unfriendly AI" (artificial intelligence). The worry seems to be that:

...any highly intelligent, powerful AI whose goal system does not contain "detailed reliable inheritance from human morals and metamorals" will effectively delete us from reality.



Can you see the similarities between dire warnings about earlier Frankenstein-style monsters and these newer, shinier, computer-generated fiends? Anything that is novel, unfamiliar, and not well understood is likely, as a first reaction, to generate fear. Too often that fear gets co-opted into campaigns to ban or strictly limit the development of new technologies. From Luddites in the 1810s to modern-day bioconservatives, we find a consistent strain of anti-Enlightenment values. Better to restrict human learning and growth than to open Pandora's Box and allow all manner of strange new creations to enter the world.

On Friday, December 4, the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies is presenting a seminar in Irvine, California, on the Biopolitics of Popular Culture:

Why is it that almost every person in fiction who wants to live a longer than normal life is evil or pays some terrible price? What does it say about attitudes towards posthuman possibilities when mutants in Heroes or the X-Men, or cyborgs in Battlestar Galactica or Iron Man, or vampires in True Blood or Twilight are depicted as capable of responsible citizenship?

Is Hollywood reflecting a transhuman turn in popular culture, helping us imagine a day when magical and muggle can live together in a peaceful Star Trek federation? Will the merging of pop culture, social networking and virtual reality into a heightened augmented reality encourage us all to make our lives a form of participative fiction?

During this day-long seminar we will engage with culture critics, artists, writers, and filmmakers to explore the biopolitics that are implicit in depictions of emerging technology in literature, film and television.


I hope you can join us in Southern California as we contemplate the monsters that populate our dreams and our fiction, and as we consider which of them might be real and scary, and which others are simply scary but unreal.

To wrap this up on a semi-humorous note, consider this warning about "The Danger of Celebrating Halloween":

During this period demons are assigned against those who participate in the rituals and festivities. These demons are automatically drawn to the fetishes that open doors for them to come into the lives of human beings. For example, most of the candy sold during this season has been dedicated and prayed over by witches.

I do not buy candy during the Halloween season. Curses are sent through the tricks and treats of the innocent whether they get it by going door to door or by purchasing it from the local grocery store. The demons cannot tell the difference.

Decorating buildings with Halloween scenes, dressing up for parties, going door-to-door for candy, standing around bonfires and highlighting pumpkin patches are all acts rooted in entertaining familiar spirits. All these activities are demonic and have occult roots.

The danger of Halloween is not in the scary things we see but in the secret, wicked, cruel activities that go on behind the scenes. These activities include:



Etc. -- and this was published, with no apparent irony, on a highly popular, "respectable" Christian website.

Meanwhile, real monsters do lurk in the world, intent on gathering illicit power to dominate and subjugate innocent victims.


This Halloween, and beyond, let's focus on the true monstrosities.