Printed: 2019-04-19

Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies





IEET Link: https://ieet.org/index.php/IEET/more/bostrom20140822

Nick Bostrom Testifies on Cognitive Enhancement for Obama BRAIN Initiative




August 22, 2014

The Obama administration’s Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues held a session on the ethical issues of cognitive enhancement, as part of the ethical, social, legal issues wing of the federal BRAIN (Brain Research through Advancing Innovative Neurotechnologies) Initiative. IEET co-founder and author of the new bestseller SuperIntelligence, Nick Bostrom was one of four asked to testify. His comments focused on the importance of ensuring egalitarian access to and benefits from cognitive enhancement.

“There are already large inequalities in cognitive capacities—partly biological, partly because different people have different amounts of education, and so forth,” said Bostrom. “One question that one can ask about a hypothetical new cognitive enhancement intervention is whether it would increase or decrease that. That might partly depend on the system we have to access [the enhancement].”

The other speakers were:

Peter Reiner, V.M.D., Ph.D., from the University of British Columbia’s National Core for Neuroethics, Kinsmen Laboratory of Neurological Research, and Brain Research Centre; Rear Admiral Peter J. Delany, Ph.D., LCSW-C, Director of the Center for Behavioral Health Statistics and Quality at the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA); Adrian Raine, Ph.D., the Richard Perry University Professor of Criminology, Psychiatry, and Psychology at the University of Pennsylvania.

Starting off the conversation with a presentation titled, “Cognitive Enhancement Past, Present and Future,” Reiner discussed the definition of cognitive enhancement. In doing so, he explained both the historic understanding and looked forward to how this definition is evolving.

“Cognitive enhancement is more complicated than it seems at first blush,” explained Reiner. “We’re already well on our way to enhancing ourselves with all sorts of drugs, devices and more.”

“I’d submit as we move forward we need to give a fair hearing to the public’s enthusiasms and fears, their utilitarian dreams and their visions for societal harmony for these are the norms to which our policies should hew,” Reiner concluded.

Delany, who oversees a SAMHSA program to collect, analyze, and disseminate critical public health data on substance abuse, mental illness, and related disorders, spoke briefly about how common cognitive enhancement is today, and how we might be able to reliably track both the prevalence of cognitive enhancement and results—both potential benefits and harmful outcomes.

Focusing on prescription drugs like Adderall and Ritalin, Delany explained that data show that people—especially college age students—who use cognitive enhancements also have increased use of other substances such as alcohol, marijuana or cocaine.

Raine later moved the discussion to the potential implications of nutrition as a cognitive enhancer and the possible use of nutritional supplements to alter behavior.

Citing extensive correlational studies about consumption of Omega-3 and a reduction in anti-social behaviors, Raine raised several ethical questions about the use of natural compounds, like fish oil, as a cognitive enhancer.
“To what extent is Omega-3 really different to drugs, medication?” asked Raine. “Our bodies don’t produce Omega-3. Yes, it’s natural, but in some ways it’s nothing short of a drug.”

“We wouldn’t give drugs to sedate prisoners. We wouldn’t give drugs to children to reduce their anti-social and aggressive behaviors. So why would we give Omega-3 to reduce such behaviors that aren’t wanted in society?” asked Raine.

Up next in this busy day, the Bioethics Commission will consider questions around direct-to-consumer neurotechnology.

See more at: http://blog.bioethics.gov/2014/08/20/considering-the-ethical-implications-of-cognitive-enhancement


Newsletter: http://ieet.org/mailman/listinfo/ieet-announce

Contact: Executive Director, Dr. James J. Hughes,
IEET, 35 Harbor Point Blvd, #404, Boston, MA 02125-3242 USA
Email: director@ieet.org
phone: 860-428-1837